Subchapter 1.2
references/advanced-redesign-protocol.mdMarkdown2 KBView on GitHub
Misclassifying a redesign is the biggest source of bad redesign output.
If ambiguous, ask once: should this preserve the existing brand, or start visually from scratch?
Document the current state first: brand tokens (colors, type, logo, radii), information architecture and nav, content blocks that do real work vs filler, signature patterns to keep, slop and broken layouts to retire, the current dial reading, and the SEO baseline. SEO migration is the top redesign risk.
Apply in order, stop when the brief is satisfied:
Rule of thumb: if IA, content, and SEO are sound, prefer targeted evolution (levers 1 to 4): about 70% of the value at 40% of the risk.
Do not modify these without explicit approval: URL structure and route slugs, primary nav labels, form field names or order (breaks analytics and autofill), brand logo or wordmark, and legal, consent, or cookie copy.